I'm looking forward to watching them all and comparing them. I feel like the battle of the five armies was anticlimactic. I'm going to wait until The Bilbo Edition is uploaded in its entirety on Vimeo since I had trouble downloading it. June 2015 And really cut the entire Azog story out of it. I wish you could shorten the battle of five armies by A LOT. Obviously before beginning all my thanks to Dustin Lee for his fantastic job. What I would like to see is a crowdsourced Hobbit adaptation that takes the best parts of the various edits and compiles them into a super edit; sound mixers, editors, special effect wizards, etc. I would just avoid it altogether. I would recommend cutting out the entire part where the goblins turn to attack dale. Helpful. all news; new fanedits; fanediting bits; reviews; site news; movie news; tech news Here's a new link with all the Swedish subtitles: This is really REALLY good. Overall, I liked it. Regarde la bande-annonce youtube.com; vudeo vudeo.net; The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies. May 4: Our Place in History (Documentary on the Kent State Shootings) Get involved! That said, I do still prefer the Maple Films fan edit, it just feels a lot richer in terms of character, and its use of extended edition scenes make for a well rounded viewing experience. I hope I come across as constructive as possible. The Two Hour cut I also really like, although it is a little too fast paced for me, especially in the beginning. 7-9 stars . https://ifdb.fanedit.org/j-r-r-tolkiens-the-hobbit-maple-films-edit/reviews I LOVED the edits to the barrel sequence. But I really like how it stand on its own both as an adaption of Tolkien's novel, and a Peter Jackson film. Vet inte varför Dustin valde att inte inkludera dem på Downloads-sidan, men alla undertextfiler finns att hämta här: I agree some of them could be trimmed down, but these sidequests add an extra layer to the story. This is corrected, the old link is removed! The Lonely Mountain violin tune near the beginning. I appreciate you taking the time to view it and give feedback! I guess I am too late for this but if you ever see this can you update the link with the subtitles for Durin's Folk and the Hill of Sorcery? The dwarves, along with Bilbo Baggins and Gandalf the Grey, continue their quest to reclaim Erebor, their homeland, from Smaug. Press J to jump to the feed. A subreddit for discussion about "The Hobbit" and Tolkien's works, be they books, movies, radio plays, music, art, you get the idea! Keeping the trilogy, and cutting each installment by 20-30 minutes gets rid of the most egregious bad decisions and dialogue created by Jackson, and still retains (and even improves) the plot and pacing. My bad. Do it a few times until you get the result you want. Take the 2 srt files prepared and place them in each folder MakeMKV. It drags on too long and has gratuitous decapitations. Tolkien's The Hobbit by Maple Films: 9.9/10 Durin's Folk and the Hill of Sorcery: 9/10 We never get a sense of any of the dwarves' personalities, they all feel like clones and aren't given any discernible features in terms of character. I wish they had an introduction like in the books (I heard they even started filming one) but considering what we have, I think you did a great job for this scene. Oct 28, 2017 2,827. As a purist, you may argue these stories is not a part of the book. Other editions (spanish and english editions availables) of The Hobbit here: http://elhobbiteditado.blogspot.com.es/2015/04/comparacion-de-ediciones-de-el-hobbit.html, Thank you so much for all the hard work! Dec 19, 2020 #60 My preference will always be the 77 animated Hobbit film over the 3 Hobbit films. J.R.R. Thank you for including Beorn's intro scene, as well as the extended scenes in Mirkwood. I'd highly recommend adding it to any LoTR movie marathon, especially with the companion piece Durin's Folk and The Hill of Sorcery. I havent seen any of the Hobbit fan-edits yet, so forgive me if my comment are somehow wrong. User reviews. 9.2 (27) Audio Editing . Hey Deykuzor, I would like to thank you for your work, it is much appreciated! http://www.deckuzdomain.com/downloads/Durin%27s%20Folk%20and%20the%20Hill%20of%20Sorcery.srt The Goblin Town chase has a few too many silly gags for my liking. That’s almost 21 hours of movie, to say nothing of breaks for cooking food, taking periodic walks, let alone sleep and other necessities. That would be cool too. Remember Me Register a new account Lost your password? 12 talking about this. Click here to jump straight to the Downloads Page. November 2015 I had to make the Swedish subs from scratch. I really don't think the changes need to be that drastic to save these movies. If someone would like to volunteer for the job, that would be awesome! Thank you for sharing. With Ian McKellen, Martin Freeman, Richard Armitage, Ken Stott. Tolkien severlerin merakla beklediği J R R Tolkien's The Hobbit Maple Films Fan Edit Filmi Türkçe Çevirisi'ni sizlere sunuyorum. I will translate the Enligsh subtitle to Romanian. So, these are the edits I've been able to find: The Tolkien Edit. Jag vet inte om det bara var ett problem från min sida eller om andra kommer uppleva samma problem, men det är anledningen till att det finns flera olika versioner. 3-5 stars . There and Back Again was the best before it got taken down. Hi there! I loved that you cut out the goblins chasing them into Rivendell. But I do understand why a lot of people don't like. I'm running Transmission on my mac as the torrent client, but the download isn't connecting to any seeds at all when I use the link on the provided page. This Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit reading order is mostly made for first-time viewers or people who have watched the movies a long time ago, and want to watch them again. February 2016 Once again, the movie franchise was directed by Peter Jackson (but not originally intended) and it acts as a prequel. Here's the link: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1V-W62vTrLSeD0AytsjfzD5RPx_m8q2VF/view?usp=sharing Conversely the Hobbit is a single, slim story (which is why it is so much more accessible)- but there is simply not enough material to stretch over 3 films (2 would have worked really well). What exactly have you cut from the Hobbit films? I was legitimately sad during the "goodbye" scene and that is an achievement from a shorter edit like this. Massive Tolkien fan, so really looked forward to the Hobbit films- trouble is that LOTR are enormous tomes with more than enough material for 3 films. Stream over 1,000 Sky movies on demand, including the latest and best films around. I feel like you could've cut some of first part of the trolls sequence, it just drags a bit too much. Thank you Maple Films for this great work. So I just got done watching Part I and I massively enjoyed it! Once the goblins capture the dwarves, shorten the sequence of when they are brought to the goblin king. The Maple Film has Azog in the same role from the original films (albeit without the flashback to the Battle of Azanulbizar). I would recommend if it is possible to either cut entirely or at least shorten the sequence where the dwarves are in the misty mountains and the stone giants are fighting. Un grand plaisir avec ce film grâce à Dustin Lee... I think these fan edits mainly serve to point out that Tolkien wrote a really oddly structured story in The Hobbit. You'll get a timer. 1-3 stars . The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug (2013) 3. I'd love to watch this fanedit, but my English is not that good. This is on Mac Catalina OSX FYI. Watch movies online. I found it was the perfect length for a Hobbit fan edit and paced itself rather well. I loved that you cut out all of the necromancer storyline. I loved that you cut the introduction to beorn and eliminated the bizarre/needlessly scary chase sequence. If you do take some of my suggestions above I would guess you could get it down to about 4 hours even, and I think it would be closer to the real story (IMHO). I also really like how there's more of an emphasis on her instead of Legolas. If you are not sure where to find them, we have a link for all six Middle-earth extended edition movies on Amazon. Still, I'm curious to see what he does with it. I made an english rendition of subtitles for Durin's Folk and the Hill of Sorcery. … J’ai modifié comme indiqué plus haut, le fichier original Fr avec Subtitle Edit pour obtenir les 2 fichiers correspondants aux iso Blu-ray 1 et 2. April 2015 You did a great job with some of these editing the goblins out, 5 stars here. Directed by Peter Jackson. Overall rating . Overall, I liked it. Did anyone figure out how to incorporate subtitles so that they work with the subtitles option in the menu? Now it's just a matter of typing in the amount of hours, minutes, seconds and decimals you want to subtract (which is a little over 2 hours). From the comments, and what I read about the edits, some of them seems to completely exclude, what I think is the better part of the Hobbit movies - namely the sidequests of Gandalf. The editing was sub par and the audio and visual quality of BOTFA was atrocious. Can someone make the Italian subtitles, please? Read more. I don't want to obsess over minutia. I've sen the Tolkien edit, There and Back Again, and the Bilbo Edition. It's not perfect however; I think the transition from AUJ to DOS is a bit awkward and stilted, and I think his colour correction for the film's opening needs some polishing. Directed by Peter Jackson. The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings movies in order – Conclusion. Once Gandalf frees the dwarves and they start running away from the goblins/goblin king, cut that sequence to just be a few shots of them running, with no/little combat. I have cut over half of the cumulative running time of the films. https://1fichier.com/?21nu8g9ubs But, I'm having trouble. (Fala galera, eu fiz uma legenda pro filme em pt br). I'm not exactly a tech expert, but I'm really intrigued to see this edit. The Bilbo Edition, while a little choppier, is still very well done, and I think I really only notice the quality of the cuts because I am currently working on my own edit of the trilogy. Oops, I must have accidentally deleted it from my Dropbox at some point. Films Streaming; Séries Streaming; Tendances; Login to your account. But could You please find a way how to integrate them into DVD or better in BR version, please? The Maple Films edit remains my favourite. Well done. This edit cuts flawlessly and has incredible work put in, such as showing Smaug flying out of Erebor without gold covering him. But I do like that the barrel sequence in the original film shows Kili's leg being wounded, which causes the company to be captured in Lake Town. Azog is also approached differently in the two cuts. It is based upon the timings of the Swedish translation, by Eric Odmyr before me, and also, things that are already in English on screen, (like subtitles for Black Speech and location names) are ignored. eng subs 1080p (1 part) The Hobbit is a great adventure story and this is most a great film of that story, bit not quite. I loved the edits to the sequence in the Elvenking's dungeons. So well done, I can scarcely even imagine the skill it took to put that together. Can anyone point me to info where I can accomplish this without having to reconvert the video into lesser quality? I've been having trouble trying to find info on the site on how to integrate the subtitle files (txt or SRT) into the Maple Films edit of The Hobbit DVD/Blu-Ray ISO file. Watch the fanedits (Bilbo edition or Maple Films. I understand how much time and effort you put into this edit. I've since found out how to split the subtitle file in two (pretty simple actually). The plan is to edit three mediocre films into one (hopefully) excellent film. 0%. 3. I'll sync Czech subtitles for complete and split versions in the future. Since there are a growing number of fan edits out there and it can be a little overwhelming which one to view, or even how to locate some of the older ones, I thought it'd be wise to get them all under one page and add new ones accordingly. all welcome to join in. Tolkien's The Hobbit. People can discuss the merits of the individual cuts either here or at their respective home pages. 201 shield misspelled -- 1321 esgaroth misspelled I don't think it adds much. I also agree that the BOFA was anticlimatic, but I blame the original film for that. - In part 1: select all the dialogue of part 2 and delete it. Disc 2: https://www.dropbox.com/s/f8zug3en5pcw4n4/jrr_tolkiens_the_hobbit_-_gersub_bluray_disc_2.srt?dl=0 If people aren't seeding, the torrent is pointless. Hi guys, I've made a subtitle in brazilian portuguese. I sat down with the intention of "just seeing if it works alright" the other night and I ended up basically watching the whole thing lol. Grab your Sky Cinema Pass for £11.99 a month. J.R.R. Jag har även gjort undertexter till Durin's Folk and the Hill of Sorcery. Removed the "http(s)" from my link, as it causes google to look for a security certificate I forgot to update. Please be compassionate about any constructive criticism you offer, as everyone involved in these fan adaptations put a lot of work, soul and passion into these labors of love. Member. Not sure why Dustin decided not to include them on the downloads page, but you'll find all the Swedish subtitle files here: Report abuse. I'm debating whether I should counter the copyright claim and argue that I'm under Fair Use (not sure if it would hold up in court but I have a fairly good understanding of Fair Use), or if I should just pursue uploading the rest of the chapters via another service, such as ZippCast or something. The Hobbit is a film series consisting of three high fantasy adventure films directed by Peter Jackson.The three films are The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012), The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug (2013), and The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies (2014). I think I'm one of the few people on this subreddit who likes the barrel sequence. I think that both of these cuts should take things from each other, but I guess they were both trying to do different things. This page is dedicated to my ongoing fanedit project for The Hobbit trilogy, titled J.R.R. I just want to watch a coherent Hobbit movie, okay? June 2016 Or anyone else can help too. But honestly the combat is mostly tame enough to watch with kids. 4. Hej Christoffer! That said, I do still prefer the Maple Films fan edit, it just feels a lot richer in terms of character, and its use of extended edition scenes make for … Mon, Dec 16, 2013 I include srt & sup thats why filesize is 18 MB.I really like how sup looks and i recommend it. Chris . In the books they more-or-less just run out the goblin gate to the east, and we next see them when bilbo bumps into them. 3 people found this helpful. Or offer us a multi-picture Hollywood deal. You can get the first hobbit movie and all 3 Lord of the rings films on Netflix so only buy the last two hobbit movies here unless you don't have Netflix but then I guess there is a 30 day free trial that you could watch it. When your making a movie, you HAVE to do this, in order to visually and structurally make it work on the screen. Any advice? Again, I must say I am blown away by your hard work and talent. congratulations for this great work!! Och om ni hittar några fel eller misstag så skriv bara här så ska jag fixa dem snarast! https://www.dropbox.com/s/jmyz1dv69reczhq/JRR%20Tolkien%27s%20The%20Hobbit%20-%20Swedish%20Subtitles.rar?dl=1, Hello!! Others may disagree but I never liked that scene in the first place. Shrouding Azog in mystery builds up a lot of anticipation for the battle of the five armies, and it's good that all allusions to Sauron are removed. July 2016 I should also mention there's a 7 hour edit, Just a heads up guys: I've finally completed and uploaded the Extended Edition final cut of The Bilbo Edition, which can be found here: https://goldfishblues.wordpress.com/2016/02/20/the-hobbit-the-bilbo-edition-2-0-extended-edition/ I've also written a comprehensive review and analysis of the 2-Hour Cut and Maple Film's 4 hour cut, comparing and contrasting them with The Bilbo Edition, creatively and technically: https://goldfishblues.wordpress.com/2016/02/19/one-editor-to-another-reviews-of-alternative-hobbit-fan-edits/. Förövrigt så hade jag lite problem med synkningen när jag använde undertexterna för DVD ISO-filerna tillsammans med Bluray ISO-filerna och vice versa. Witness the defining chapter of the Middle-Earth saga Dec. 10, 2014 New Zealand 144 Min. I did my best, but perhaps more tinkering could resolve this? The plan is to edit three mediocre films into one (hopefully) excellent film. 1. Also, some things appear completely out of context with little to no cinematic build up. DVD COVER ART. JRR Tolkien's The Hobbit. Then follow these steps. December 2015 Now, The Tolkien Edit... honestly I didn't care for The Tolkien Edit at all. I guess if I could make a request it would be to consider maybe making a version with as little gore as possible. - In part 2: go to the menu Synchronization and select Adjust all times. Also if you cut out any gratuitous decapitations so I could watch it with my daughter, that would be incredible! I managed to download The Bilbo Edition by /u/DanielU92 (it worked!). Amazing film, I used it to binge watch the hobbit/Lord of the rings so yeah. Anyway, you can find it on my website at this Url, right clicking and "Save As" will work, or you can just click it, ant it'll pull up a browser view of my work you can save onto your own subtitle formatter I guess. The opening of the film feels a bit awkward due to the different music than in the original. ): fantastic version of hobbit- I really enjoyed it ! I find it interesting that all these fan edits cut the movies down to just 2-4 hours. And THERE'S AN INTERMISSION. I also wasn't a fan of the Goblin Cave sequence, I think the way it was cut originally is a lot smoother, and the ensuing action sequence has a little too much unnecessary silliness for my liking. Here are my thoughts: The opening is perfect, I loved it. Vous pouvez obtenir mes sous-titres Fr sur ce lien : October 2015 Audio/Video Quality . And I haven't seen the Maple Film version yet, but I've heard nothing but good things and I'm looking forward to it. All will have a good time. Do you have a release date in mind for Part II? Hello Eric! I would argue they are still a part of the Tolkien universe and a valid reason to fill out the gaps in the movie. You have three options- a Bluray set in Bluray case dimensions, a Bluray set in DVD case dimensions, and a DVD set in DVD case dimensions. Now to my point: http://tinyurl.com/TheHobbitSweSub I watched all six Hobbit and Lord of the Rings films back to back to back to back to back to back, and all in their Extended Editions (the only way to watch the films, as will be assumed throughout this post). (i didnt write this-- its a fast copy paste from various sources). Do you have english subtitles for Durin's Folk and the Hill of Sorcery so I can sync a Czech version based on them? September 2015 27 reviews. I've been looking for a definitive list of the different fan edits. New subtitles Fr: https://1fichier.com/?fw5x862ve7. The way you handled the wargs sequence was fantastic, it flows incredibly well. 9.8 5 votes. And most of the stuff with Bard's family. We finally get a real indication of a good character, instead of a female character who is bogged down in a cheesy love story. Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 22 June 2020. The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies (2014) Like us on Facebook! 5-7 stars . 3.0 out of 5 stars If you expect the same quality as L O T R, then you might be disappointed. I think I will finish my PG version first just so I don't accidently steal any creative ideas from the hard work MF put into his. I'd be hard-pressed to offer you much advice. Archives. Hi. Download the two iso files. The name of my production company is Maple Films. I had not seen BotFA before watching Maple Films and it made me want to go back and watch all three originals again. 7%. First of all: A big thank you for your efford! Tested and proved! Still, Durin's Folk and the Hill of Sorcery is well put together, and definitely worth the watch. I'd still prefer practical effects for the orcs, but Maple Films can't really change that. DarkSora. I don't know if that's just an issue on my end or if others will have the same issues, but that's why you'll find several different versions of the subtitles. You've gotta find a balance between the two, and not be such a purist, or overly concerned about the length of the films to lose sight of that. https://1drv.ms/u/s!AlDKyYuAmgRsgp5xYirGaIY9gT276A Om den ena inte synkar korrekt för dig så använd bara den andra! It wasn't what I imagined reading the books, and it also went on a bit too long IMO. The gollum sequence is very good. I actually like the barrel sequence, but I have the same issues with this sequence as I do with the Goblin Town chase. It's cool. A curious Hobbit, Bilbo Baggins, journeys to the Lonely Mountain with a vigorous group of Dwarves to reclaim a treasure stolen from them by the dragon Smaug. I do like the "Cut the ropes!" :p, I'm going to work on a slightly shorter PG version of TBE and I'll definitely take your feedback into consideration :).